The federal government's $200 billion plan to
prop up consumer lending is likely to come with strings banks won't
like: new regulations curtailing predatory lending practices.
"It makes no sense at all for the government to
protect or increase the availability of credit card loans while
allowing credit card issuers to continue to use unfair and deceptive
practices," says Travis Plunkett, legislative director at the Consumer
Federation of America.
Earlier this week, the U.S. Treasury and Federal
Reserve announced plans to extend low-rate loans designed to help banks
shore up their portfolios of credit card and other consumer loans.
Consumer advocates and reform-minded lawmakers say that move should
open the door to much stricter regulations on how banks charge high
rates and penalty fees.
A USA TODAY two-part investigative series on
credit traps revealed how banks sharply boosted credit card rates and
fees, then enticed consumers to take out home equity loans to pay off
high credit card balances. The series also explored how banks packaged
credit card debt to be sold as securities to Wall Street investors.
Selling credit card debt as securities gave banks a powerful incentive to boost profits via high rates and penalty fees.
Banking industry officials say high rates and
fees reflect how risky the borrower is. Now, as low-rate public loans
get made to buttress banks' credit card portfolios, the federal
government will enjoy unprecedented leverage to impose reforms, should
it choose to do so, says Gail Hillebrand, senior attorney for Consumers
Union. "We certainly should not be spending our tax dollars supporting
rip-off practices while waiting for credit card reform," she says.
Robert Lawless, bankruptcy law professor at the
University of Illinois, predicts credit card reform will become a high
priority for the Obama administration.
"The credit card industry has built a profit
model off of people's mistakes, and that's got to change," Lawless
says. "The American people won't want to be co-owners of an industry
that uses trickery to make money off the backs of the middle class."
Earlier this month, Sen. Chris Dodd, D-Conn.,
chairman of the influential Senate Banking Committee, vowed to
strengthen protections for individual borrowers.
Sen. Robert Menendez, D-N.J., says the timing
may be ripe. "We're seeing a confluence of issues," Menendez said in an
interview. "We have a perfect set of circumstances that will drive not
only transparency, but true reform."
He calls for restrictions on interest rate
increases, a ban on the issuing of credit cards to unemployed juveniles
and college students, and a ban on charging interest on penalty fees.